I'm not gonna rate each song individually, 'cause I'm feeling lazy But I think this is their best album, there're songs that, IMO are weaker than others e.g The Only Exception, Looking Up, Misguided Ghosts. But apart from those tracks I find it to be a very solid album. When I finally got it from iTunes Friday, I shut myself in my room to listen to it with no interruptions, and as the album progressed I kept thinking, wow this is such a good album, yet there hasn't been a song that's just BAM, really hit me, yunno?! But then, All I Wanted started and woah, Hayley's vocals are all kinds of amazing!! Chills!!!
I've listened to it quite a lot now, and I find I'm loving the songs more and more each time!